Skip to content

The real cost of context switching, and what the research says.

Every jump to another tab, app or chat feels like it takes a second. The research says the real cost comes after the jump, while your mind finds its place again.

5 min read · · BeqSpark team

In short

  • In one study of 137 office workers, people switched between apps and websites about 1,200 times a day.
  • The switch itself is quick. Getting your focus back is what costs time, and it costs more on hard or unfamiliar work.
  • Famous numbers like "23 minutes to refocus" are real, but usually quoted out of context.
  • The best fix is fewer trips: bring what you need to where you work, and finish small things before you move on.

How often we really switch

In 2022, three researchers writing in Harvard Business Review followed 137 people on 20 teams at three Fortune 500 companies for up to five weeks. On average, each person switched between apps and websites about 1,200 times a day.

A single switch took only a couple of seconds. But the authors estimated that getting reoriented after switching added up to just under four hours a week, about 9% of people's time at work. Over a year, that's roughly five working weeks.

Most of those switches weren't people getting distracted. In one company in the study, a single supply-chain transaction took about 350 switches across 22 applications and websites. The switching was the job, spread across too many places.

Why a switch costs more than it feels

Psychologists call it the switch cost. In a well-known set of experiments published in 2001, Joshua Rubinstein, Jeffrey Evans and David Meyer had people alternate between tasks such as solving maths problems and sorting shapes. People lost time at every switch, and they lost more when the tasks were complex or unfamiliar.

In the lab, one switch can cost as little as a few tenths of a second. The American Psychological Association sums up Meyer's view this way: those brief mental blocks can add up to as much as 40% of someone's productive time. Note the as much as: it's the upper end, for heavy switching between demanding tasks, not an average for everyone.

There's a second cost, which the management researcher Sophie Leroy named attention residue. When you leave a task unfinished, part of your mind stays with it. In her 2009 experiments, people who moved on from an unfinished task kept thinking about it and did worse on the next one. Finishing the first task, especially under a little time pressure, left less of it behind.

The "23 minutes" number, in context

You've probably read that it takes 23 minutes to get back on track after an interruption. The figure comes from Gloria Mark, who studies attention at the University of California, Irvine. In a 2008 interview with Fast Company, she said that about 82% of interrupted work was resumed on the same day, but that it took an average of 23 minutes and 15 seconds to get back to it, usually with two other tasks in between.

So 23 minutes is how long it took people at work to return to an interrupted task while they handled other things, not how long a brain needs to refocus after a glance at a notification. The lesson still holds, though: one interruption tends to pull in others before you get back.

Mark's lab work adds a useful twist. In a 2008 experiment, people who were interrupted finished their work in less time and just as well, but reported more stress, frustration, time pressure and effort. We make up for interruptions by pushing harder, and we pay for it in how we feel.

Her later research found that people now stay on one screen for about 47 seconds on average before switching, down from about two and a half minutes when she first measured it in 2004. (Steelcase interview with Gloria Mark)

What helps

You can't remove switching from modern work, but you can cut the trips that don't need to happen.

  1. Bring the tool to the work. Many switches exist only to fetch something: a translation, a definition, a quick answer from a chat assistant. Every time you copy text into another tab and paste the answer back, you leave your work and come back. Doing it where you are removes both trips.
  2. Finish small things before you move on. Leroy's research suggests unfinished tasks follow you. If a reply takes two minutes, send it, then switch. If it can't be finished, write down where you stopped and what's next, so your mind can let go.
  3. Batch the checking. Read email and chat at set times rather than on every ping, and turn off the notifications that are never urgent.
  4. Protect the hard work. Switch costs are highest on complex, unfamiliar tasks. Give those a block of time with nothing else open.
  5. Close what you're done with. Every open tab is a small reminder asking for attention. If your tabs have become a to-do list, there are better places for it.

Sources

  1. Harvard Business Review: How Much Time and Energy Do We Waste Toggling Between Applications? (Murty, Dadlani and Das, 2022)
  2. American Psychological Association: Multitasking: Switching costs
  3. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes: Why is it so hard to do my work? The challenge of attention residue when switching between work tasks (Leroy, 2009)
  4. Fast Company: Worker, Interrupted: The Cost of Task Switching (2008)
  5. CHI 2008: The cost of interrupted work: more speed and stress (Mark, Gudith and Klocke)
  6. Steelcase: Our 47-second attention span, with Gloria Mark

Try it

Any text, on any page. Even in a video.

Free to install, with 50 credits every month and no card needed.